AYCF: Allegations against INEC chairman, unfounded

INEC Chairman, Yakubu Mahmood

The Arewa Youths Consultative Forum (AYCF) has described recent criticisms leveled against the chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Yakubu’s Mahmood, following the Edo governorship election as unfounded.

AYCF in a statement by its President General, Yerima Shettima said it firmly believes in the importance of a credible electoral process and stands in solidarity with INEC amidst unfounded allegations of electoral malpractice, adding that the essay will address the key criticisms,  which highlighted INEC’s efforts towards electoral reform, and emphasise the importance of constructive engagement in strengthening Nigeria’s democracy.

According to Shettima, “Several criticisms have emerged, primarily focusing on the alleged ineffective utilization of the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) and the Election Viewing Portal (IREV). Accusations range from deliberate malfunction to a complete disregard for these technological advancements”. 

The AYCF further acknowledges that challenges were encountered during the election, but these challenges do not equate to deliberate manipulation or a systemic failure of the systems themselves.  

“Rather, operational shortcomings in implementing protocols and managing the logistical complexities of a large-scale election are more likely explanations.

“It’s crucial to differentiate between genuine technical difficulties and deliberate sabotage; attributing the former to the latter undermines the efforts undertaken by INEC to improve its processes.  

“The claim that INEC deliberately refused to implement BVAS and IREV is not only misleading but also damages the credibility of serious accusations of misconduct.

“It is important to understand the historical context in which INEC operates. Nigeria’s electoral history is marred by allegations of manipulation, administrative inefficiencies, and a lack of transparency.  However, attributing all these failings solely to INEC is unfair and unproductive.  

“The commission operates within a complex political landscape with resource constraints and immense pressure to deliver free and fair elections. INEC’s consistent adoption of new technologies, like BVAS and IREV, demonstrates its commitment to improving electoral integrity.

“The willingness to learn from past mistakes, as evidenced by the INEC Chairman’s statements in Akure, highlights the commission’s dedication to continuous improvement and accountability.Related News

“While individuals like Martins Obono and Jerry Wright-Ukwu have presented accusations against INEC, including “damning, incontrovertible evidence,”  it is crucial to approach such claims with a healthy dose of skepticism and critical analysis.”

Shettima said in a democratic society, the burden of proof lies with the accuser, stressing that the accusations require rigorous investigation and verification before they can be accepted as fact, adding that relying on unsubstantiated allegations only serves to erode public trust in INEC and undermines the democratic process. 

The AYCF advocated for a thorough examination of all claims, ensuring that any evidence presented is subjected to independent scrutiny and that the spread of unsubstantiated accusations of institutional rigging and conspiracy only serves to create division and distrust.

Moving forward, particularly in preparation for the 2027 elections, the AYCF called for collaborative support for INEC instead of engaging in a cycle of blame and mistrust, all stakeholders – political parties, civil society organizations, and the electorate – must work together to strengthen the electoral system. 

“This requires several key actions: advocating for increased financial and administrative autonomy for INEC, enhancing its capacity through training and professional development, and establishing robust and transparent oversight mechanisms.  

“The AYCF firmly believes that improving INEC’s effectiveness is vital for strengthening Nigerian democracy, and this requires constructive criticism, rooted in evidence and aimed at creating solutions, not merely leveling accusations.

“The Arewa Youths Consultative Forum unequivocally supports INEC in its efforts to conduct free and fair elections.  While acknowledging the challenges faced by the commission, we reject unfounded allegations and calls for undermining its authority.  

Shettima said, the path to credible elections lies in building up our institutions, not tearing them down.  Constructive dialogue, evidence-based criticism, and collaborative efforts are vital to improving Nigeria’s electoral process. 

The AYCF urged all stakeholders to work together, fostering a transparent and accountable environment that ensures the voice of the Nigerian people is heard and respected, stressing that only through collaborative efforts can we ensure the continued progress of our democracy and build a stronger, more credible electoral system.